Even if you put two photographers in the same place, it doesn’t mean they will make the same photographs. While I hate to use myself as an example, I will do so because,…well, …because, …well because it’s my blog and I can write what I want. Harrumph.
Brooks Jensen (Editor of LensWork) and I have photographed together for more than thirty years. We’ve been up and down the West Coast of both the United States and Canada and to such remote locations as Mongolia and North Dakota. We have photographed together in the very same spots. We are convinced each other has completely missed the artistic merit of the location we are photographing. The only thing we have both succeeded in is being wrong about that. Our photographs from the same place are not remotely similar.
The sum and substance of it is we photograph the same thing differently. Not just a little bit differently, but a whole bunch differently. Our approaches to the subject, composition of the image, the post capture processing (or for you traditional types, darkroom techniques and practices) are very different. I think the basis is that we just don’t see the same photograph when we look at the same thing. That’s how I feel about it and I bet Brooks will disagree with that, too.